Pension Election Tool

Compare lump-sum vs lifetime annuity, single-life vs joint-and-survivor, with or without COLA. One-time, irrevocable choice — see the present value of each option side-by-side.

📖 About this tool

What it does

Compares your pension's lump-sum buyout offer against the lifetime monthly options (single life / 50% J&S / 100% J&S) on present-value math. Shows cumulative income over time for each path so you can see when each crosses the lump sum invested.

Who this helps

Anyone with a defined-benefit pension making the one-time, irrevocable election decision at retirement. Often a $200K-$1M+ choice with no easy heuristic.

How to use it

  1. Enter the lump-sum offer from your employer.
  2. Enter the monthly amounts for each annuity option (single life / 50% / 100% J&S).
  3. Pick a COLA assumption (most private pensions: 0%).
  4. Enter your age, life expectancy, and your spouse's age + life expectancy.
  5. Set the investment return you'd expect on the lump sum if you took it.
  6. Read the present-value comparison and the verdict.

What it doesn't do

Doesn't model the PBGC guarantee limit (~\$87K/yr at 65 in 2026 for single-employer plans) — relevant if your former employer is at risk of insolvency. Doesn't model spousal PV separately when ages differ widely.

The Offers

Lump Sum

Annuity Options (monthly amounts)

Life Expectancy

Investment Alternative

If you take the lump sum, what would it earn invested? Compare lump-sum-invested vs each annuity option.

Comparison

Cumulative Income Over Time